Mark & the Mysterians: The First Punk Rock Band
by Mark Guerrero
Question Mark & the Mysterians was a
pre-punk rock band that was formed in Michigan in the early
'60s. It is widely believed that the term "punk rock"
was first used in reference to them by Dave Marsh, a writer
who often contributed to Rolling Stone magazine. The
band was mysterious by design. They named themselves
after a Japanese science fiction film called "The Mysterians,"
in which aliens from the destroyed planet Mysteroid come to
conquer the earth. Question Mark was actually lead
singer Rudy Martinez, who was born in Texas in 1945 and grew
up in Saginaw, Michigan. He always wore sunglasses and
claimed he was from Mars and in a past life lived among the
dinosaurs. (Humans did not live in the time of dinosaurs,
but what the hell we can go with it.) The other
members of the band were also from the Saginaw area and like Rudy had come north with their migrant
worker families from Texas. Question Mark & the Mysterians will
always be remembered for their classic garage rock gem, "96
Tears," which hit #1 on the national charts in the fall of
The original band members of The Mysterians were
Mexican-Americans Larry Borjas on guitar, Robert Martinez on
drums, and Bobby Balderrama on lead guitar. They formed in
Bay City, Michigan in 1962 inspired by surf bands and artists
like Link Wray and Duane Eddy. (After Question Mark & the Mysterians'
success with "96 Tears," Bobby met Duane Eddy on one of their
tours at a hotel. Bobby was nearly speechless meeting one
of his guitar heroes.) Needing a bassist in the band ,
Larry volunteered to switch to bass. They began playing gigs in
and around Adrian, Michigan. After seeing English bands
they admired such as the Dave Clark Five and The Animals with
organ players, The Mysterians added 14 year old Frank Rodriguez,
Jr. on Farfisa organ. Needing a strong lead singer and
front man, The Mysterians added a friend of Robert Martinez by
the name of Rudy Martinez (no relation, later to become Question
Just before the band was scheduled to begin recording, Robert
Martinez on the verge of being drafted, joined the army. Larry Borjas
decided to enlist with him using the buddy system to keep the two friends
together. They were replaced in The Mysterians by drummer Eddie Serrato
(Question Mark's brother in law) and bassist Frank Lugo, a member of a local
Mexican band. The classic "96 Tears" lineup was
now in place.
Rudy Martinez (Question Mark) had written a poem called "Too Many
Teardrops" several years before the band was formed. He
eventually put a melody to it, but since he didn't play an
instrument the song had no chord structure behind it.
Meanwhile, The Mysterians had created what was to be the music
bed and arrangement for which Rudy Martinez' song would fit.
According to Bobby Balderrama, Eddie Serrato suggested they call
the song "69 tears" because it would be different and more
interesting to have the number of tears that had fallen. The
band thought the song could be banned from radio airplay with
the suggested title so Eddie suggested "96 Tears, a simple
reversal of 69." Everyone agreed and the rest is history.
The idea of the name Question Mark came from David Torrez, who
worked for Dow Chemical in Midland, Michigan. He was
interested in managing the band at the time and thought Question Mark & the Mysterians was a great name since
the ? gave additional mystery to
the band's image. He also suggested that the other members
be known as X, Y, and Z, but that didn't take hold for very long.
Question Mark & the Mysterians recorded "96 Tears"
on March 14, 1966 in a back room of a private
house in Bay City, Michigan as a
single for local Pa-Go-Go Records,
owned by the group's manager Lillian Gonzales. Bobby Balderrama
remembers having to move a pool table to make room
for the band.
Bobby thinks they did about 10 or 11 takes at the insistence of
their producer, Rudy Gonazalez, who was also a musician with his
own popular Texas-based band, Rudy & the Renobops. Since
the record was recorded on a two-track machine, the band played
and Question Mark sang live at the same time, no overdubs. For their first single it was originally intended as the "B"
side of "Midnight Hour." At Question Mark's insistence, "96 Tears" was
picked as the "A" side. Lillian Gonzalez
initially manufactured only 500 records and told the guys to
start promoting it. Question Mark and Bobby Balderrama took "96 Tears"
to the local Saginaw rock station WSAM, who started to play the
record and get some positive reaction from their listeners.
Question Mark and Bobby then sent one hundred postcards to the station with
made up names and addresses requesting "96 Tears." This
brilliant marketing move got them more airplay and local stores
where Question Mark and Bobby had already placed records started to sell
them out. They then hit other stations in nearby towns
such as WTAC in Flint with the same positive result.
Eventually the record got picked up by CKLW in
Detroit, where it became #1. At this point Lillian
Gonzalez and the band realized they needed national
distribution. Offers came in from several record companies,
Lillian and the band went with Cameo-Parkway, a label made famous by Chubby
Checker and Bobby Rydell. "96 Tears"
eventually sold over a million copies.
After the band's success, Rudy Martinez legally changed his name
to ?, not Question Mark, but the symbol. In interviews he
would not give his given name and continued to say he was from
Mars. He did this in all seriousness and never broke a
smile. He always wore sunglasses while performing,
recording, being interviewed, or photographed and still does
to this day. Question Mark & the Mysterians second single in 1966
was "I Need Somebody," which peaked at number 22 on the national
charts. Subsequent singles, including "Can't Get Enough Of
You Baby," and an album called "Action," didn't do so well
commercially even though the band's musicianship was maturing
and improving. "Can't Get Enough of You Baby" was brought
to the band by Neil Bogart, who later had great success in the
disco era with his Casablanca Records. Question Mark & the Mysterians went on to record for
other labels such as Capitol, Tangerine, Super K, Chicory, and
Luv, but by 1973 the band had run its course. "Can't Get
Enough of You Baby" would eventually reach #14 on the U.S.
charts in 1998 when covered by a Southern California band, Smash
Mouth. Mel Shacher, later to play with Grand Funk
Railroad, played bass for a time with ? and the Mysterians.
He was replaced by Richard Schultz, who co-wrote a song with ?
called "She Goes To Church On Sunday," which is currently with
Paul McCartney's publishing company. "96 Tears" has been
covered by many artists and has become a classic rock standard.
With a major hit on their hands, Question Mark and the Mysterians toured
around the country and did a lot of television shows. One
six week tour had them on the bill with Sky Saxon and The Seeds
(Pushin' Too Hard"), The McCoys ("Hang On Sloopy"),and
Sonny Geraci and The Outsiders ("Time Won't Let Me"). They were also brought to
Hollywood to appear on Dick Clark's "American Bandstand."
While in Hollywood Question Mark & The Mysterians opened for the Leaves
("Hey Joe") at a popular Hollywood venue.
In the early '70s, Question Mark & the Mysterians reformed with a new
lineup with two guitars, bass, and no keyboards. Their
sound and style inspired writer Dave Marsh to coin the term
"punk rock" in a 1971 article he wrote about Question Mark & the Mysterians for Creem Magazine. Question Mark had always claimed he'd been
to the future and was ahead of his time. Maybe he wasn't
so far off base when one considers even the early Question Mark
& the Mysterians were punk rock and their sound on "Can't
Get Enough of You Baby," copied by Smash Mouth thirty two years after Question
Mark & the Mysterians recorded it, still sounded hip and shot up the
charts. In 1980, "96 Tears" was covered by Garland
Jeffreys and became a minor hit. In 1984, Question Mark & the Mysterians had a reunion in Dallas, Texas, where they opened for
Joe "King"Carrasco. A recording was made of their
performance entitled "96 Tears Forever: The Dallas Re-Union
Tapes" and released by a New York City label called ROIR. In
1997, the original members of the band reunited once again and
this time began to
play shows. They collaborated with promoter Jon
Weiss, who made the band headliners at his CaveStomp Garage Rock
festivals. CaveStomp revived many garage rock and
psychedelic bands of the 60s. The revitalized Question
Mark & the Mysterians established themselves as one of the best and
strongest re-formed bands on the circuit and played many
mid-sized concert venues from 1997 through 1999. They also
made two trips to Europe, where in November of 1998 they blew
away the audience at the Wild Weekend Garage Rock show in
London. They returned to Europe in the summer of 1999,
culminating with a show at the Royal Festival Hall classical
music venue as part of the "Meltdown 1999" music festival.
Since Question Mark & the Mysterians were unable to secure the rights to
their original master tapes, they recorded a new version of the
entire "96 Tears" album in 1997 and released it on the
Collectables label in 1997. "Do You Feel It Baby," a live
album was released in 1998 on Norton Records. Another
studio album followed called "More Action," produced and
recorded by Jon Weiss in 1999. Due to some dissatisfaction
with the record and some business issues, Question Mark & the Mysterians
went on another hiatus. In the 2000s Question Mark & the Mysterians
still play occasional shows. On January 9, 2007,
home burned down and he lost all his possessions, including his
memorabilia. Also lost in the fire was the original Farfisa organ used on "96 Tears."
In September of 2008, I had a long phone conversation with
Question Mark in
regards to a PBS show on which I was a talent coordinator and
performer, eventually called "Trini Lopez Presents: Latin Music
Legends." I was trying to secure the participation of
Question Mark & the Mysterians for the show, which also included El Chicano,
Tierra, Thee Midniters, The Greg Rolie Band, and of course Trini
Lopez. I sang a song backed by Tierra on the show, which
aired on some PBS stations in 2009. I could not convince him to
come out to California to do the show. Part of the reason
was he didn't want to fly. He said he would come by train
and needed his manager to come with him. As it turned out
the producers and Question Mark did not come to terms and consequently he
didn't do the show. However, on my long conversation with
Question Mark, which lasted at least an hour and a half, he told me his
history and philosophy. I heard tales of his time travel,
Martian origins, and got an insight to his limitless
self-confidence as a performing artist. As fate would have
it, less than a year later, I met him while doing a show on the
same bill with Question Mark & the Mysterians. On May 22, 2010, I
was playing as a member of Cannibal & the Headhunters at a
taping of another PBS special in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Question Mark & the Mysterians were also taping on that night. As it
turned out, they were the second to last band to perform and we
were the last, doing our song around midnight. Cannibal &
the Headhunters and Question Mark & the Mysterians were the only
Mexican-American groups on the bill. We spent some time
hanging out with some of the members. I mainly spoke with
Bobby Balderrama, the lead guitarist, and we exchanged cards.
I, along with members of the Headhunters, also posed for photos
with Question Mark.
A few years after Question Mark & the Mysterians broke up in 1969, Bobby
Balderrama joined Joe "King" Carrasco's band in Texas.
Carrasco was doing well recording and touring the country.
They also played the college circuit, sometimes on the bill with
Stevie Ray Vaughn and the Fabulous Thunderbirds.
Interestingly enough, Joe "King" Carrasco is not Latino, but
German-American. He took the name Carrasco from a modern
outlaw. He described his music as Tex Mex Rock. The
music and his attitude also had some '80s rock elements.
He would jump into the crowd, mosh pit style, in the days before
the practice had really caught on. Bobby Balderrama currently has a
smooth jazz band called The Robert Lee Revue, Robert Lee being
Balderrama's first and middle name. Also in the band is
Mysterians keyboardist Frank Rodriguez, Bobby's wife on percussion, his son Nicolas
on rhythm guitar, and a sax player. The Robert Lee Revue has an album out
entitled "For the Love of Smooth Jazz," which is getting a lot
of internet radio airplay, including in London, England. A
second album is in the works and will be out shortly.
Bobby first got interested in jazz when George Benson burst on
the scene in the '70s. Bobby admired Benson's guitar style and virtuosity on recordings such as his jazzy version
of "On Broadway." Smooth jazz has become a passion for him
Balderrama. So much so, he plans to do a podcast called
"Great Lakes Bay Jazz Radio" in the near future. For more
information on the Robert Lee Revue, visit
In 2011, Question Mark & the Mysterians are still occasionally performing.
Sadly, Mysterians drummer, Eddie Serrato passed away on February
24, 2011 of a heart attack at the age of 65. Because of their timeless classic "96 Tears" and
the unique and mysterious image they've portrayed, Question Mark
& the Mysterians will always be
remembered in the annals of the history of rock & roll.
They are considered by many to be the first punk rock band and
are often referred to as "the world's greatest garage rock
band." Happily, their music is still available on many reissues
"96 Tears Forever - The Dallas Reunion Tapes '84" (1995 ROIR),
"Question Mark & the Mysterians (1997 Collectables), "Do You Feel It Baby"
(1998 Norton Records), "More Action" (1999 Cavestomp! Records),
"Feel It! The Very Best of Question Mark & the Mysterians (2001 Varese
Sarabande), and "The Best of ? and the Mysterians - Cameo
Parkway 1966-1967" (2005 Cameo-Parkway/ABKCO).
There's also a documentary on Question Mark & the Mysterians in progress by Terry Murphy
called "Are you For Real?"
This article is
based on a telephone conversation with Question Mark by Mark Guerrero
in September 2008 and a phone interview with Bobby Balderrama on July 24, 2011.